Ingest defence, and make Bonferroni cumulative across the programme
Two things shipped that stand regardless of sample. DEFENCE. Statcast Outs Above Average is free on the host we already pull six feeds from, so there was nothing to decide. 514 fielders, aggregated to team level -- the unit a batter's prop actually needs, the defence behind the pitcher he faces -- and persisted as 31 team rows. Verified in production. Cubs +56 best, Mariners -29 worst. Unknown is not zero, and it bites unusually hard here: an OAA of 0 is a REAL reading meaning exactly average, so coercing absence to 0 would assert that every unmeasured fielder is league-average, which is the commonest defensive profile there is. team_defense also carries as_of_date in its primary key from the first row -- statcast_aggregates was built upsert-in-place and that silently made every backtest leak the games it predicted, so point-in-time is available here before it is needed rather than after a wrong answer. A bug worth recording as a class: BASE already ends in /leaderboard, so the new feed built a doubled path and 404'd. Because a failing feed degrades to an empty index by design -- correct, so one broken source cannot fail the whole pull -- it surfaced as "fielding_oaa: 0 rows", which reads exactly like "Statcast has no fielding data". Graceful degradation makes a wiring bug look like an honest absence. CUMULATIVE CORRECTION. Bonferroni had been applied per session throughout: a run testing eight features corrected by eight. Across a programme's lifetime that is wrong in the dangerous direction, because every order gets a fresh generous alpha and the false-positive rate compounds quietly. Correcting by 8 when sixty have been tried is how a noise result eventually gets recorded as PROVEN with a p-value to point at. The denominator is now distinct hypotheses ever tested, persisted, and it moved 19 -> 38 within this session alone, alpha 0.0026 -> 0.0013. Re-tests deliberately do not inflate it: re-asking the same question on more data is not a new shot on goal, and counting it would punish the discipline of waiting for sample. THE MEASUREMENT. The differential the theory predicted is present: defence correlates with the counter's residual at +0.130 for GHOST, the contact and speed archetype, and -0.018 for BOMBER, the power archetype. A GHOST's hits depend on whether anyone can range to the ball; a BOMBER's barrels clear the defence entirely. So a flat BOMBER result is the theory working rather than the test failing. It is not a result. GHOST is n=104 against a 500 bar, with p=0.188 against a corrected alpha of 0.0013 -- three orders of magnitude short. Both are recorded as CANDIDATE with their measured lift, tagged contact-skill, so the re-run at full sample compares against a recorded baseline. Nothing proved, so nothing was recalibrated and nothing shipped. 4,228 tests green (336 suites); web build exit 0. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01W1sivYNqY2TS5ftykmHBU9
This commit is contained in:
@@ -1496,6 +1496,39 @@ phased plan in the Session-57 conversation / BUILD-STATE Next section).
|
||||
- Within BOMBER, the counter still leads on hits (0.218 vs 0.160) — consistent
|
||||
with the closed pooled hits negative.
|
||||
|
||||
## Defence ingest + cumulative Bonferroni (Session 87 — non-obvious)
|
||||
- **BONFERRONI IS NOW CUMULATIVE ACROSS THE PROGRAMME LIFETIME**
|
||||
(`src/services/model/testLedger.js` + `mc_test_ledger`). Correcting per-session
|
||||
(8 tests → /8, forever) let the false-positive rate compound silently; the
|
||||
denominator is now DISTINCT hypotheses ever tested. Demonstrated: 19 → 38 in
|
||||
one session, α 0.0026 → **0.0013**. RE-TESTS DO NOT INFLATE IT — re-asking the
|
||||
same question on more data is not a new shot on goal, and counting it would
|
||||
punish waiting for sample. The alpha only ever shrinks, so prefer re-testing
|
||||
standing candidates over inventing new hypotheses — that is now mathematically
|
||||
the disciplined choice.
|
||||
- **DEFENCE IS INGESTED** — free Statcast OAA (`FEEDS.fielding_oaa`), 514
|
||||
fielders → `team_defense` (31 teams, dated). Team-level is the right unit (the
|
||||
defence behind the pitcher faced). `oaa_sum` + `oaa_mean` (mean because a team
|
||||
with more measured fielders would else look better for being measured more);
|
||||
<3 fielders → absent. **OAA 0 is a REAL "exactly average" reading** — coercing
|
||||
absence to 0 asserts every unmeasured fielder is league-average, the commonest
|
||||
profile there is. `team_defense` carries `as_of_date` in the PK FROM ROW ONE
|
||||
(the statcast_aggregates lesson, applied before it was needed).
|
||||
- **`BASE` in statcastAdapter ALREADY ENDS IN `/leaderboard`** — the new feed
|
||||
doubled it and 404'd. And because a failing feed degrades to an EMPTY index by
|
||||
design, it surfaced as "fielding_oaa: 0 rows", which reads exactly like
|
||||
"Statcast has no fielding data". **Graceful degradation makes a wiring bug look
|
||||
like an honest absence — treat any feed reporting 0 as suspect until the URL is
|
||||
fetched by hand.**
|
||||
- **THE DEFENCE DIFFERENTIAL APPEARS AS THEORY PREDICTS:** solo r vs counter
|
||||
residual is **+0.130 for GHOST** (contact/speed, n=104) and **−0.018 for
|
||||
BOMBER** (power, n=245). A GHOST's hits depend on fielder range; a BOMBER's
|
||||
barrels clear the defence. **A flat BOMBER result is the theory working, not
|
||||
the test failing.** Both UNDERPOWERED (p=0.188 vs corrected α 0.0013) — a
|
||||
signal shape, not a result.
|
||||
- `team_defense` keys on Savant's DISPLAY NAME (a nickname, "Cubs") while game
|
||||
logs give full names ("Chicago Cubs") — match on both.
|
||||
|
||||
## Active Skills
|
||||
- vyndr-voice (all user-facing output)
|
||||
- prop-analysis (grading methodology)
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user