vyndr/specs/pre-audit-status-pull.md

VYNDR — PRE-AUDIT STATUS PULL (report-only, 2026-07-31)

Re-derived from the CURRENT repo (10aaaeb) + live prod probes. Nothing inherited from the previous matrix. Nothing built, wired, or changed.

---

PHASE 0 — THE TWO OPEN PROMOTION ITEMS

0.1 — THE 92.9% RE-LETTER DID NOT HAPPEN. NOTHING WAS PROMOTED.

Stated plainly: there is no live re-lettering to explain. The promotion gate failed last order (3 of 4 prerequisites unmet) and the flip was not performed. Verified three independent ways just now:

• HEAD is 10aaaeb ("promotion gate not passed — no flip"), clean tree, nothing landed since.
• efficiencyShading is imported by ZERO production files — still measured-never-served.
• Live grades carry 0.0% A-family: MLB n=5 {B:1, C:4}, WNBA n=25 {B:15, C:10}. A promoted shading model would show ~79% A.

Neither 92.9% nor 43.6% is a figure this project measured. The numbers actually measured on the challenger, against all 1,250 ledger rows, were: 97.4% of grades would change, 79.8% moving UP, producing 79.0% A-family — with 0 of 1,250 rows actually shaded by efficiency. The re-letter would have come entirely from switching the grading basis to edge-vs-fixed-bar, not from efficiency shading (inert: 96.5% of markets unscored, the one scored market is the f=1 anchor). That is why it was not flipped.

The live board today is the unchanged additive factor-index champion.

0.2 — TAG STATUS

tag	state
Takeable tags	✅ LANDED. 1,245 of 1,250 rows tagged, takeable_floor recorded on all 1,245, 1 distinct floor (−160). The 5 untagged are rows with no locked price (honest NULL).
Model-version boundary	⚪ NOT PRESENT — and correctly so. model_version holds only the S64 era labels (engine1@2026-07-20, pre-retention-unknown). There is no recalibration boundary because there was no recalibration. This is NOT a gap to fix before the audit; it becomes a hard prerequisite the day a promotion actually happens.

---

PHASE 1 — REFRESHED COMPLETION MATRIX (re-derived, not inherited)

LIVE = prod probe. WIRED = a user can reach it (nav/tab/drawer link, or a real importer).

#	Surface	DES	BUILT	WIRED	LIVE	HONEST	DONE	Evidence / gap
1	Landing / hero	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	/→200; hero ranks on takeable p_win (07-29 fix), honest empty state
2	Dashboard / Slate	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	/dashboard→200; snapshot grades real (MLB 5 / WNBA 25)
3	Scan flow	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	/scan→200; honest NoMarketState
4	Grade result card	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y↑	✅	3 importers; edge_pct display RETIRED 07-31 — EDGE now honest-absent —
5	Grade badge	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	B/C only live, no fake A
6	Ledger	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	/ledger→200; n≥20 gate honored
7	Tier-record	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y*	✅	n≥20 gate; *A-tier glow is ranking-as-credibility
8	Pricing	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	/pricing→200; Stripe real
9	Public profile /u	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	privacy 404 identical for unknown/unpublished
10	Player profile	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	reachable via playerHref
11	Team hub	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y*	✅	*MLB real; NBA/WNBA partial roster
12	Explore	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	2 nav links; /explore→200
13	WIRE / ticker	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	/api/ticker→200, real exhaust
14	Streaks / hot list	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	/api/streaks/mlb→200
15	Live tracking	N	Y	Y	Y	Y	❌	DESIGN gap — no artboard in the bundle (spec only)
16	Parlay lab	P	Y	Y	Y	Y	⚠️	/parlay→200 but 0 nav links — reached via the #parlay drawer only
17	Alt-line ladder	P	Y	P	Y	Y	❌	Desk-gated; rung edge % retired 07-31, line+grade still render
18	Book comparison	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	✅	RESOLVED — BookComparisonPanel has a real importer, on the grade card
19	Price triplet	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y	❌	honest NO_MODEL; still ❌ because the EV layer does not produce values
20	Compare (H2H)	P	P	N	Y	Y	❌	/compare→200 but 0 nav links; honest in-dev state
21	Newsletter	N	Y	Y	P	Y	❌	DESIGN gap (no artboard); Listmonk env CANNOT DETERMINE
22	Slip reader	N	Y	N	Y	Y	❌	/slip→200, 0 nav links = orphan; design = spec only
23	Article media (S3)	Y	P	N	P	Y	❌	ShareCard has 0 real importers — still DEAD
24	Calibration / edge board	Y	Y	N	N	Y	❌	MobileEdgeBoard 0 importers — correctly dead/hidden
25	System / Intelligence terminal	Y	Y	N	P	Y	❌	/intelligence→200 but 0 nav links; /system→404
26	Offseason hub	Y	P	N	N	—	❌	/offseason→404, never built

Counts

FULLY DONE (all five YES): 14 of 26. (1-14 minus #15, plus #18.) Precisely: Landing · Dashboard · Scan · Grade card · Grade badge · Ledger · Tier-record · Pricing · /u · Player profile · Team hub · Explore · WIRE/ticker · Streaks — plus Book comparison = 15.

1.3 Call-outs

• DESIGNED-but-not-BUILT: only Offseason hub (#26) — full Vyndr Offseason.dc.html spec, no page (prod 404).
• BUILT-but-not-WIRED (dead code): ShareCard (0 real importers — S3 article media), MobileEdgeBoard (0 importers — correctly hidden until a real edge feed), DemoScan (0 importers). Book comparison is RESOLVED — it was the headline dead component and is now routed to the grade card.
• LIVE-but-not-HONEST: NONE FOUND. Every known fabrication is removed or hidden: /compare honest in-dev, MobileEdgeBoard pulled, price triplet NO_MODEL, and the edge_pct "620% edge" display retired 07-31. (Honest state = "no KNOWN live fabrication", not "provably none".)
• Orphan pages (live, 0 nav links) — UNRESOLVED: /intelligence, /soccer, /marketplace, /notifications, /slip, /compare, /parlay (drawer-only). /system and /offseason are 404 (never built). /terminal→307 redirect to /dashboard, by design.

---

PHASE 2 — IS THE DESIGN COMPLETE? NO — three surfaces lack design, not build.

The S-series bundle (specs/design-reference/) covers: Landing · Mobile · System · Intelligence · Offseason · Price Triplet · Scanner States + HANDOFF.md.

Surfaces where DESIGN itself is the gap (code exists, no design artboard):

1. Live tracking (#15) — built and live, spec only (specs/LIVE-TRACKING.md), no artboard.
2. Slip reader (#22) — built and live, spec only (specs/a1-s9-slip-reader.md).
3. Newsletter / THE WIRE (#21) — engine built, spec only (specs/feature-a1-s7-newsletter.md).

Partial design: Parlay lab (#16) exists only as "PARLAY BUILDER" inside System.dc.html, not a named artboard; Compare (#20) and Alt-line ladder (#17) have no dedicated design.

So: design is complete for the core funnel (landing → dashboard → scan → grade card → ledger → pricing) and incomplete for three shipped-but-undesigned surfaces plus one designed-but-unbuilt (Offseason).

---

PHASE 3 — CHROME AUDIT MANIFEST

Every surface flagged "→ Chrome audit" across recent orders, i.e. every visual that could not be verified from the backend. State = the session each must be checked in.

#	Surface / route	State to check in	What to verify
1	Grade card /scan	free + ENTITLED (Desk)	EDGE cell renders —, not a % (Order B). No "620% edge" anywhere. Grade letter + projection still render.
2	Book comparison on the prop card	free + entitled	Panel renders per-book lines; single-book honest copy; no crown (BOOK_CROWN_ENABLED=false); self-hides when no books.
3	Alt-line ladder on the grade card	ENTITLED (Desk) only	Rungs show LINE + GRADE, no % figure; base rung marked; ladder ordered by line.
4	Top-graded board /dashboard	logged-out AND ENTITLED (Desk)	Board renders ≥1 row (it was empty for months). Logged-out: NO p_win/ev_pct/model_odds in the payload but order still correct. Entitled: p_win present — the path I could not test from the backend.
5	Hero / landing /	logged-out	Top read renders with grade + timestamp; honest empty state if nothing qualifies; no +EV/best-bet claim.
6	Price triplet	free + entitled	NO_MODEL honest-absent ("—"/"NOT PRICED"), no false "poisoned" copy.
7	/soccer	logged-out	Renders; no "% edge" (Order B retired it here too).
8	Ledger /ledger	entitled	n≥20 gate honored, "RECORD BUILDING" under sample; CLV column honest.
9	Orphan pages /intelligence, /marketplace, /notifications, /slip, /compare	logged-out	Confirm each renders honestly (or should be pulled/linked). /compare must show the in-dev state, not Jokić/Wembanyama.
10	/system, /offseason	logged-out	Confirm 404 is intended (never built) rather than a broken link from somewhere.
11	Mobile (≤768px)	logged-out	Bottom tab bar present; MobileEdgeBoard absent (phones show real cards).

🔑 Items requiring an ENTITLED (Desk) session — only Kev can drive these

#1 (entitled half), #3 alt-line ladder, #4 entitled top-graded board, #8 ledger. Everything else is checkable logged-out or on a free account. #4 is the highest-value item — the strip-after-rank boundary was proven in the payload but its entitled rendering has never been seen.

---

TAGS

VERIFIED: no promotion occurred (three ways); takeable tags landed; matrix re-derived from live probes + importer/nav counts; design bundle inventory. CANNOT DETERMINE: Newsletter LIVE (Listmonk env not visible from outside). BLOCKED: none.